St Paul Tavern St Paul
St Paul Tavern Logo

St Paul Tavern

@

4.51495 reviews

St Paul Tavern offers great food and drinks in a friendly atmosphere. Located in the heart of St Paul, this tavern stands out with its diverse menu and vibrant events. Guests can enjoy a variety of cocktails, beers, and delicious meals on-site or to-go.

The atmosphere is inviting, fostering a sense of community. From karaoke on weekends to live music, there’s always something happening here. The tavern accommodates everyone, making it a perfect spot for families or solo diners.

With its casual vibe, St Paul Tavern attracts both locals and visitors. The decor exudes warmth, making it a welcoming space for all. Stop by and enjoy a meal in an environment that feels like home. The friendly staff adds to the enjoyable experience.

About

St Paul Tavern is tucked away on North Webster Street. This small-town eatery has a rich history, bringing locals together since it opened its doors. It’s more than just a restaurant; it's a gathering place for friends and families.

Over the years, this tavern has seen countless memories created—birthdays, anniversaries, and casual hangouts. Its charm lies in its ability to make anyone feel at home. The regulars know each other by name, fostering a sense of belonging.

The location plays a crucial part in its success. It’s easily accessible, making it a go-to spot for many. With the tavern's welcoming atmosphere, it's clear why both locals and travelers keep coming back for more.

Get in Touch

103 N Webster St, St Paul, IN 47272, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday 11:00-22:00
  • Tuesday 11:00-22:00
  • Wednesday 11:00-22:00
  • Thursday 11:00-22:00
  • Friday 11:00-01:00
  • Saturday 11:00-01:00
  • Sunday 11:00-22:00

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"Good food in a small town. The wife and I came here while working out of town. She had the chicken bacon ranch sandwich, and I had the pulled pork plate. Both were very delicious, and the portion was plentiful. We also had the potato kegs for an appetizer, which was filling in itself. The had live music going, and we didn't have to wait long to be seated. I would recommend this place for sure."

- Kevin E.

"If you're looking for an authentic small-town experience with unbeatable food, St. Paul Tavern is the place to be. Known for its legendary fried frog legs, this spot delivers a dish that's surprisingly lean, flavorful, and downright delicious. From the moment you walk in, you're embraced by the warm, hometown charm that defines this establishment. The sense of community and town loyalty is palpable, making it a welcoming stop for locals and visitors alike. One of the standout features of St. Paul Tavern is its incredible value. In 2025, finding an all-you-can-eat deal for just $15.99 is nearly unheard of, making it possibly the best bargain in the entire state. Whether you're here for a casual meal or a night out with friends, this tavern serves as a fantastic watering hole that perfectly captures the spirit of St. Paul. If you're passing through or looking for a unique dining experience, don't miss out on this hidden gem. St. Paul Tavern is a true treasure where great food, friendly faces, and unbeatable deals come together in the best way possible."

- Phil P.

"We made a trip to see this place. In a small town people were great... friendly, welcoming environment. Service was spot on. We were already full so we just ordered pizza nachos not bad. Next time we plan on eating not snacking"

- Robert E.

"Nothing better than a small town Tavern. Great staff and regular customers. Best fried chicken around and great pizza too"

- Paul F.

"Family room for kids, bar side with full bar and large variety of beers available. Several TVs in both rooms for entertainment while enjoying your meal. Server wasnt overly welcoming but done the job required. Large menu for a small town bar, lots of options that sound great. We wanted a variety so we ordered Chicken Livers, Sidewinder Loaded Fries, Breadsticks with Cheese and Pepperoni/Sausage Pizza. Hubs said the livers were good flavor and hot. Sidewinder Fries were covered with jalapeno cheese and bacon. Breadsticks had a slight garlic taste perfectly paired with the jalapeno cheese. Pizza looked amazing, however it didn't have much flavor. I am hoping it was from all the jalapeno cheese that our taste bubs were overwhelmed but would likely try other items before reordering the pizza again."

- Elizabeth K.

"I'd like to give 3.5, all in all it was a decent place, all non smoking including the bar so that was nice. Older place, but clean. Staff was nice and tag teamed the whole time. We went because we'd heard good things about the breaded tenderloin, I wasn't really impressed. The meat was grisly for lack of a better word. The seasoning on the coating was decent, but it wasn't particularly crunchy. So in general decent flavor but not good texture. The size was slightly bigger than the bun. Fries were really floppy, not crispy at all. My son liked his food (I don't remember the name of the dish he ordered)."

- Lisa D.
Write a Review

Why Visit

Visiting St Paul Tavern is a must for anyone seeking a quaint dining experience in Indiana. The tavern boasts exceptional value, offering all-you-can-eat specials that are rarely found elsewhere. For $15.99, indulge in unique dishes like fried frog legs or mouthwatering chicken dinners.

The menu is diverse, including everything from burgers to pizzas, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Consider the chicken bacon ranch sandwich or try their pulled pork. These dishes are tasty and generously portioned, making them perfect for sharing.

Besides good food, the tavern regularly hosts events. Catch live music or join in on a night of karaoke. Fridays become lively as locals gather, making it a fun night out. The warm community vibe makes the visit even better, drawing families and friends together.

Most Liked things

Guests rave about the incredible food and generous portions. The fried frog legs are a must-try, showcasing a local culinary twist. Many enjoy the inviting and friendly atmosphere, making every visit special.

People appreciate the fast service, allowing them to focus on enjoying their meals. The diverse drink menu also garners praise, particularly its variety of craft beers and creative cocktails. Friends gather here to unwind after a long day while sipping on their favorite drinks.

Most Disliked things

Some diners mention inconsistency in food quality, particularly with certain dishes. While many love the pizza, a few find it lacking in flavor during their visits. Feedback about side items, such as the fries being too limp, has also surfaced.

Additionally, some guests feel the service could improve during peak hours, particularly on busy weekends. The bustling atmosphere can sometimes lead to slower service, which might affect the overall experience.

FAQ

What kind of food does St Paul Tavern serve?

St Paul Tavern offers a diverse menu. Enjoy tasty sandwiches, pizza, and kid-friendly meals. Don't miss the bacon cheeseburger, buffalo chicken pizza, and all-you-can-eat specials on specific days.

Are there any special events at St Paul Tavern?

Yes, St Paul Tavern hosts live concerts, karaoke nights, and sports screenings. It's a lively place to enjoy great drinks and company while catching up on your favorite games.

Is there parking available at St Paul Tavern?

Yes, St Paul Tavern has accessible parking. You can find free parking both onsite and on the street. Accessibility ensures a comfortable visit for everyone.

What is the price range at St Paul Tavern?

Prices at St Paul Tavern typically range from $10 to $20. It's affordable for delicious food and drink, making it a great choice for casual dining.

Can I make a reservation at St Paul Tavern?

Absolutely! St Paul Tavern accepts reservations. It's a good idea, especially during busy nights or special events.